'Ideology' remains significant factor in Villalba-Aleman terrorism charge
Just as day five of the weeklong sentencing hearing for the University of Waterloo the attacker was wrapping up, Justice Frances Brennan and federal prosecutor Howard Piafsky had an intense exchange over the concept of ideology in relation to the terrorism charge.
In the Canadian criminal code definition, a terrorism act must satisfy three components.
• For a political, religious or ideological cause
• Committed with the intention of intimidating the public
• Intended to cause serious violence to people
Most of the arguments court heard have been over ideology and if the court can consider Villalba-Aleman’s broad collection of right-wing grievances as an ideology.
Several times Justice Brennan asked Piafsky to define Villalba-Aleman’s ideology.
“I’m concerned the definition you are asking me to adopt is so broad we will dilute what we mean by terrorist motivation,” said Justice Brennan.
The crown argues that the law does not require a tidy ideological view to be considered terrorism.
"This is exactly the type of activity we want this terrorist legislation to cover,” said federal prosecutor Howard Piafsky.
Telling the court its not the attackers’ beliefs that are an issue, it’s his actions, ““You can have all types of ideas, but you cannot act in a violent way to promote your ideas,” added Piafsky.
According to experts, this type of murky ideology in violent attacks is becoming more common.
“The director of the FBI told the US Senate in 2022, there's a kind of “salad bar” of ideology out there, especially on the far right, where individuals kind of pick and choose like a salad bar, which beliefs they're going to hold on to and that they're going to see as motivating.” Said Lorne Dawson, distinguished professor emeritus at the University of Waterloo.
Dawson, whose research is focused on terrorism and radicalization, says this type of attacker is different.
“They're not your classic terrorist, they don't belong to a group they haven't sworn allegiance to particular leaders, they haven't received instructions to do something,” said Dawson.
He says people radicalized online often have a unique collection of motivations.
“So it things become quite fuzzy and difficult, and you usually have to do it case by case.”
Dawson, however, appears to agree with the crown, being able to easily identify the ideology of the attacker is not critical.
“As soon as you fall into those components that you think your action has significance beyond your personal circumstance, and that it has a kind of political or intimidating component to it, it starts to look like terrorism,” says Dawson.
Justice Brennan set aside January 25, 2025 to deliver her decision.
If found guilty of terrorism Villalba-Aleman could serve as much as 16 years, if his crimes are not terrorism or found not to be hate motivated, the defense is recommending a sentence of six years.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Clothing recyclers frustrated by chaos, violence plaguing some clothing donation bins
An organization that represents clothing recyclers says they’re frustrated after a W5 investigation found a fake charity and some violent players connected to organized crime have been muscling in on the clothing donation bin industry, and is calling for governments to do more.
Poilievre promises to abolish federal sales tax on new homes under $1 million
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre says if his party forms government, it will scrap the federal sales tax on new homes sold for less than $1 million and push provinces to do the same.
'Pieces of wood': Gummy candies recalled, Canadian Food Inspection Agency says
A recall has been issued for gummy candies due to pieces of wood, according to the Canadian Food Inspection Agency.
Austrian mayor shot dead with suspect on the run, police say
A manhunt is underway in northern Austria after a hunter allegedly fatally shot two people and fled the scene, local police said Monday.
Ont. couple accused of human trafficking plead not guilty as trial gets underway
Marred by several delays, the trial of alleged human traffickers Lauriston and Amber Maloney is underway Monday in a Bradford courtroom, with both entering a not guilty plea.
NEW 'We promise to be better': N.S. firefighter club criticized after group in KKK costumes attends Halloween dance
A group of Cape Breton firefighters are apologizing after four people showed up at a Halloween dance dressed in what appeared to be Ku Klux Klan costumes.
Why a group of Canadian doctors says workplace sick notes need to go
Canadian doctors are calling for employers and schools not to require sick notes when it comes to short-term minor illnesses.
Next CPP payment coming on Tuesday for Canadian retirees
Here's how retirees will get their funds from the federal benefit.
Colin Farrell finishes Dublin Marathon while pushing friend in a wheelchair
Colin Farrell took time out from his acting schedule on Sunday to complete the Dublin Marathon – while pushing an old friend in a wheelchair.