Municipal candidate suing City of Cambridge over alleged election mistakes
Municipal candidate suing City of Cambridge over alleged election mistakes
A candidate in Cambridge’s 2022 municipal election is taking the city to court, asking a judge to determine whether the vote was valid.
Nate Whalen finished second in the race to represent Ward 3, a result he says he’s happy with as a first-time candidate. But he claims he witnessed numerous issues throughout the course of the election that led him to launch a lawsuit.
“It’s not one or two mistakes - or a few mistakes - that might not make a huge difference to the election or might not impact the results,” Whalen says. “In this case, there are dozens of examples that we’ve come up with and identified that were not in accordance with the municipal elections act.”
Among his numerous concerns is the decision two days before voting day to postpone the election for the area’s Waterloo Catholic District School Board (WCDSB) trustees after it was discovered two candidates’ names were missing from the ballot.
Whalen is also questioning why one potential candidate was told after the nomination deadline she could not run due to a missing signature while another candidate was allowed to re-submit illegible documentation after the same deadline.
Whalen also lists concerns around scrutineering and technology issues on election day that he believes impacted voters abilities to cast a ballot.
Whalen says this is all especially important in light that there were a number of close races.
“About 10 of the 17 positions were elected within 5 per cent of the electorate, and some of them were 46 votes, 100-something votes, so it’s not many in a population of 95,000 or so electors,” Whalen says.
Whalen says that while a byelection would be inconvenient, it is one possible outcome of the case.
“It’s the right thing to do, to hold a byelection, if the judge decides it was not a valid election process full of integrity.”
The City of Cambridge declined to speak with CTV News about the case, with a spokesperson writing, “this is a legal matter which is before the courts. To ensure the integrity of that process, the City of Cambridge will not engage in discussion about this matter in the media and has no further comment.”
However, an affidavit filed by City Clerk Danielle Manton as part of the case outlines the access provided to scrutineers and states “there was no interruption to the ability to vote online during election day.”
Whalen says campaign financing rules mean he is currently forced to represent himself in this case. He’s hoping the lawsuit will make its way through the system relatively quickly, given it involves election results. But he’s also hoping his efforts will set new standards.
“The ultimate goal is to make sure that there is accountability in this election, so that we create precedent that is educating clerks and municipalities all across Ontario to help them do elections better,” Whalen says.
Whalen adds it’s important people are able to trust the electoral process and the results. “It’s about our collective future and making sure democracy is well respected for years to come.”
POLITICAL SCIENTIST SPEAKS OUT
Retired political science professor Peter Woolstencroft says he was “stunned” by the way the Cambridge municipal election unfolded.
In particular, Woolstencroft has concerns about the WCDSB trustee ballot error, saying he’s never heard of another case in Canada where an election had to be stopped and redone because of missing names on the ballot.
“I do have a serious concern about the do-over school board election because I think there is an advantage for people who do have access to money and a disadvantage to people who don’t have access to money,” he says.
Woolstencroft wonders if the results would have been different without the need to redo that particular vote.
Woolstencroft says having a judge review the election is worth it, given the numerous concerns, adding it’s “peculiar” to have so many things happen in the same election.
“Accidents happen, human systems fail us, people make mistakes. But there is a cost. There’s a question of trust.”
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delivered a speech to Ukraine's parliament, where he called the war-torn country's fight against Russia's invasion a battle 'for the future of us all.' This comes after Trudeau announced Canada will be spending $500 million to help Ukraine's military fight Russia's invasion.
Fires across the country are burning millions of hectares of land but what does that really look like? CTVNews.ca compared the blazes to some cities and lakes in the country showing just how big they have gotten.
Foreign interference special rapporteur David Johnston has resigned, CTV News has confirmed. In a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Johnston cited the intense politicization of his appointment and work, as the reason for his coming departure.
Ahead of the release of her interim report on progress as Canada's special interlocutor on unmarked graves at former residential schools, Kimberly Murray says lawmakers at all levels of government shouldn’t be waiting for her findings to act.
A Ukrainian-Canadian teenager is on an emotional journey to capture the destruction of the Russian invasion, including of his childhood home, on camera.
A recent study published in the peer-reviewed journal Preventative Medicine Reports by a group of international researchers has found that post-secondary students with unhealthy eating habits can go on to suffer from disease and mental health issues for years to come.
Former U.S. president Donald Trump is facing 37 felony charges related to the mishandling of classified documents, according to an indictment unsealed Friday that alleges that he described a Pentagon 'plan of attack' and shared a classified map related to a military operation.
Showers are predicted Saturday over the aggressive wildfire threatening Tumbler Ridge, but forecasters say thunderstorms could sweep through the parched region without bringing any rain.
Three men found guilty in the shooting death of a local woman, a mother opens up after her teenage daughter’s body was recovered by police, and a man was charged with the murder of his estranged wife. Here’s a look at the top stories on ctvnewswindsor.ca this week.
Stevenson Memorial Hospital (SMH) in Alliston is warning residents about fraudulent activity within the community regarding an advertising opportunity.
Ottawa police say four men were located on Clarence Street with gunshot wounds at approximately 1:30 a.m. Two of the men suffered life-threatening injuries.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delivered a speech to Ukraine's parliament, where he called the war-torn country's fight against Russia's invasion a battle 'for the future of us all.' This comes after Trudeau announced Canada will be spending $500 million to help Ukraine's military fight Russia's invasion.
Auditor General Nathalie Gougeon says the fraud hotline has been receiving approximately five to 10 reports a day over the past year linked to bus operator "compliance nature", and it is overwhelming her office.
Toronto police have released images of a vehicle used by three suspects to flee the scene of a violent attack outside of a Scarborough mosque last month.
The next 48 hours will be crucial in Quebec's wildfire fight in northern and western parts of the province, with rain forecast for Monday but warmer, humid temperatures expected until then.
Three of the province's nine Cree communities are threatened by wildfires, including Waswanipi and Mistissini. But only Oujé-Bougoumou, about 500 kilometres north of Montreal, has been evacuated completely.
There is a divide at the Mohawk Council of Kanesatake that seems bound to complicate the process of cleaning up a toxic dump that has the potential to hurt the wider environment north of Montreal.
Police say a woman in central Nova Scotia has been fined nearly $29,000 for having an unsupervised outdoor fire in the midst of a provincewide fire ban.
Nova Scotia says it has identified more details about the records stolen in a file transfer service cyber attack, impacting teachers, students and health care workers' records.
WINNIPEG -- Zach Collaros was glad Blue Bombers fans were able to cheer just as much at the end of the game as they did early on in Winnipeg's 42-31 victory over the Hamilton Tiger-Cats on Friday.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delivered a speech to Ukraine's parliament, where he called the war-torn country's fight against Russia's invasion a battle 'for the future of us all.' This comes after Trudeau announced Canada will be spending $500 million to help Ukraine's military fight Russia's invasion.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delivered a speech to Ukraine's parliament, where he called the war-torn country's fight against Russia's invasion a battle 'for the future of us all.' This comes after Trudeau announced Canada will be spending $500 million to help Ukraine's military fight Russia's invasion.
Ahead of the release of her interim report on progress as Canada's special interlocutor on unmarked graves at former residential schools, Kimberly Murray says lawmakers at all levels of government shouldn’t be waiting for her findings to act.
The Moby Dick restaurant has been serving up its famous fish and chips on the White Rock promenade since it was founded by the Mueller family in 1975. But one local city councillor clearly isn’t a fan.
Authorities in West Vancouver say it's lucky more people were not harmed when a driver crashed his car through the entrance of a Whole Foods Friday, coming to a stop in the busy produce section.
