First responders testify at second-degree murder trial of Erick Buhr
Warning: This story contains details that some readers may find disturbing.
Four witnesses testified Wednesday at the trial of Erick Buhr, who has pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder in the death of his grandmother, Viola Erb.
Proceedings began with Buhr’s frantic call to 911 on Sept. 24, 2022.
“My grandma’s been murdered,” he told the dispatcher. “I came in and she’s done, she’s gone.”
Buhr explained that he’d been outside and, upon returning to the home they both shared, he found the 88-year-old Erb.
“There’s blood all over the place,” he said on the 911 call. “I was outside. I came back and the door was open.”
The dispatcher then asked if he was able to perform CPR.
“I tried… she’s gone,” Buhr replied.
When asked who he thought could have hurt his grandmother, he replied: “No, she was the sweetest lady ever.”
Buhr also said he dragged Erb towards the stairs and put water on her face, but was unable to “wake” her.
At that point in the call, first responders had arrived at the home, which was located just outside of Baden.
First witness
The paramedics who took the stand on day two of Buhr’s trial described what they saw at the scene.
Andrew Simmons, along with his partner Sara Clemens, arrived at the home around 1:28 p.m.
Erb, he said, was laying on her back in the kitchen with blood pooled around her head.
“There was also quite a bit of… other blood,” he added, referring to smears and splatters in the surrounding area.
Simmons testified to seeing trauma or bruising on Erb’s face, specifically her head and eyes.
He also said Erb had a weak carotid pulse.
Simmons and Clemons then began lifesaving measures but that was ultimately called off.
Twelve minutes after their arrival, Erb was pronounced dead.
Simmons testified, during cross-examination, that he saw what looked like dried blood at the scene. When asked how he knew that, Simmons said it didn’t appear to be sticky or shiny.
He also stated that Buhr seemed “frantic.”
Second witness
Clemons was next to testify.
“I saw a woman lying on the ground… [and] copious amounts of blood,” she recalled. “There was a lot of trauma to her face and there was blood all around.”
Clemons described the scene as “chaotic.”
She said Buhr was in the kitchen while they worked on Erb.
“Sort of pacing around nonsensically, I guess,” she testified.
Clemons confirmed that Erb had “massive” facial injuries and, initially, a weak pulse. A short time later, however, they were unable to get a heartbeat.
She also noted that Erb’s chest felt unstable and she thought it may have been a broken rib.
Third witness
The jury also heard from two police officers.
Const. Cameron Dorland, of the Waterloo Regional Police Service, said there was “blood all over the floor” when he arrived.
He also described Erb as being “beaten up really bad.”
Dorland testified that he didn’t notice any signs of forced entry into the home.
Video from his body camera was also shown to the jury.
“I searched for a pulse and there was nothing,” Buhr was heard saying. “I didn’t feel a thing.”
Dorland, with his gun drawn, then went to search the home.
Buhr described his reaction to finding his grandmother to Dorland’s partner, Const. Christopher Lacroix.
“What do I do? What the f--- do I do?” he could be heard saying.
Buhr told the officer that when he found his grandmother he tried to move her and then stopped.
“What the f--- am I doing?” he said in the video. “This is dumb. So I dragged her back.”
Then, Buhr told the officer, he called 911.
Lacroix asked Buhr twice if he had changed his clothes when he returned home and Buhr replied, both times, that he did not.
“I tried, I tried, I tried to save her,” he could be heard saying. “I tried to put cold water on her. I didn’t know what to do.”
During cross-examination, Buhr’s lawyer asked about the doors at the home. Dorland said the basement door was locked, but could be opened from the inside. He also said the door from the living room to the deck was unlocked.
Fourth witness
The last witness to take the stand was Lacroix.
“I noticed [Buhr] was sweaty,” he recalled. “When I first arrived he was out of breath as well.”
Lacroix also testified that he saw blood on Buhr’s hands and legs, as well as scrapes on his legs and feet.
He didn’t notice any blood on Buhr’s clothing.
Later, Lacroix stated, Buhr wanted to go back into the home to retrieve drugs because he didn’t want to be charged with possession.
During cross-examination, Lacroix said Buhr asked to go upstairs to get some cigarettes. Lacroix followed him up and testified that he didn’t see him take or hide any clothing.
When Buhr was told Erb had died, Lacroix said “he was upset.”
Lacroix also testified that he knew Buhr when he was younger but the two had had no interactions as adults.
Buhr’s trial will continue on Thursday.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Poilievre writes to GG calling for House recall, confidence vote after Singh declares he's ready to bring Liberals down
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has written to Gov. Gen. Mary Simon, imploring her to 'use your authority to inform the prime minister that he must' recall the House of Commons so a non-confidence vote can be held. This move comes in light of NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh publishing a letter stating his caucus 'will vote to bring this government down' sometime in 2025.
BREAKING At least 2 dead and 60 hurt after a car drives into a German Christmas market in a suspected attack
A car plowed into a busy outdoor Christmas market in the eastern German city of Magdeburg on Friday, killing at least two people and injuring at least 60 others in what authorities suspect was an attack.
Judge sentences Quebecer convicted of triple murder who shows 'no remorse'
A Quebecer convicted in a triple murder on Montreal's South Shore has been sentenced to life in prison without chance of parole for 20 years in the second-degree death of Synthia Bussieres.
'I understand there's going to be a short runway,' new minister says after Trudeau shuffles cabinet
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau added eight Liberal MPs to his front bench and reassigned four ministers in a cabinet shuffle in Ottawa on Friday, but as soon as they were sworn-in, they faced questions about the political future of their government, and their leader.
Fake nurse Brigitte Cleroux sentenced for B.C. crimes
A woman who impersonated nurses in several provinces has been sentenced to seven years in prison for offences in British Columbia – where she illegally treated nearly 1,000 patients across multiple communities.
Poilievre to Trump: 'Canada will never be the 51st state'
Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre is responding to U.S. president-elect Donald Trump’s ongoing suggestions that Canada become the 51st state, saying it will 'never happen.'
A new book about Chrystia Freeland just came out. Here's what we learned
A new book about Chrystia Freeland has just come out, after the publishing company sped up its release date by a few months. CTV News sifted through the book and pulled out some notable anecdotes, as well as insights about Freeland's relationship with the prime minister.
Toronto officials warn of possible measles exposure at Pearson airport
Toronto Public Health (TPH) is advising of another possible measles exposure at Canada’s largest airport.
Bail denied for Winnipeg woman accused of killing animals in online videos
Warning: This story contains disturbing details. Discretion is advised. A Winnipeg woman accused of making videos of animals being tortured and killed that were sold on the dark web was denied bail.